Tuesday, June 18, 2019

Understanding Alchemy

In one of my earlier posts I compared several different models of the spiritual life. Here I wanted to look at a model that I neglected: alchemy.

In the chemistry courses many of us take in school, alchemy is usually mentioned briefly as an early version of the discipline. The textbooks will usually make some sort of mention about those quaint alchemists "trying to turn lead into gold" and then go on to explain all the ways modern chemists have surpassed them.

While it is true that some medieval alchemists did work with chemicals, on close inspection the discipline is much more than this. When we unpack it, we find its symbols are a cover for their real enterprise, a great inner "work" that takes place within man.

Now you may ask, "Why all the confusing symbols?" I think the best answer to this is to look at the times and places where alchemy was practiced. If we do so we find that it developed in settings that were often not known for their tolerance - where those practicing "alternative" spiritualities were likely to be branded as heretics. So, the schema of alchemy was developed as a cover for them to work without persecution.

Goals of the Alchemists
Let's look at a few major models of alchemy, then compare them to the other descriptions of the religious life we've examined.

To start, what is the goal of the alchemist? Usually there are several different ideals.

1. To turn the base metals into gold
2. To create the elixir of life
3. To create the philosopher's stone
4. To complete the "magnum opus" (great work)

We find that these are all describing a similar end, although the emphasis is placed on different areas. Let's try to unpack what each of these means.

1. This first goal makes use of the symbolism of metals. In alchemy, there are usually the "base metals" (lead being the lowest) and the "noble metals" (gold being the highest). The alchemists that did work with physical chemicals would attempt to transmute (via various processes) the base metals into valuable gold - as we know, to no avail.

From the allegorical perspective, these metals are describing an inner work. The base metals represent ordinary man - man in an "uninitiated," "ignorant," or "unrepentant" state - while gold represents the state of self-perfection, enlightenment, or wisdom - the state of the "divinized" or "deified" man.

2. The second goal places its focus on the creation of the "elixir of life" - the idea being that by consuming this secret drink one will attain immortality. This perspective usually has all sorts of colorful descriptions of how this elixir is made.

I have some sympathy with this description, as I feel it is alluding to the greatest problem of human beings - death. To me, any seriously minded person should be working diligently to overcome death, and I feel this description is an expression for someone on this path.

An interesting anecdote here is the tale of Shi Huangdi. Towards the end of his life the Chinese emperor became absolutely terrified of dying. So, he gathered all the alchemists from throughout China and set them to work to make him the elixir of life. They produced many liqueurs for him to consume, but one of these was a potion of mercury, which (ironically) was what caused his death. Here we can learn from the emperor, and remember these are figurative formulas - not literal ones.

3. The third goal is to create the "philosopher's stone," and I always found this an interesting one because it in itself makes reference to the overlap that happens between disciplines.

So, are we working with alchemy here - or philosophy? It is an interesting question. Who we should immediately think of here when we use the term "philosopher" are of course the ancient Greeks, Plato and Socrates, who coined the term, and who described the praxis one on this path should follow in works like The Republic, the Phaedo, the Timaeus, and so on.

I have already covered the three parts of the psyche described in The Republic earlier, and touched on how this work is itself an allegory. The Republic explains the establishment of justice within the psyche, and compares the psyche of the normal man (the tyrannical city-states) to the psyche of the higher man (the philosopher, the Kallipolis or beautiful city).

We also find throughout the dialogues Socrates describing much of the lifestyle that one on this path would follow. He explains the heroic and ascetical temperament, and the pursuit of wisdom as major practices. He also speculates on the nature of reality, justice, the afterlife, and other topics that one on this path would consider of interest.

4. The final goal of the "magnum opus" is compatible with each of the others, and is of value because I think it reflects the overall perspective of alchemy. Alchemy is different from other spiritualities because it sees itself as a life process of work that permanently transforms the human being. For the alchemist, he is the material with which he works; he is the "prime matter" that is turned into the "gold" of wisdom, perfection, and immortality.

The Philosopher's Stone
Having looked at the goals, let's look at two major formulations of the alchemical path. The first is usually presented as the following.

1. Blackening (nigredo)
2. Whitening (albedo)
3. Reddening (rubedo)

This model is usually presented as a means of creating the philosopher's stone. First, the alchemist begins with the first matter (the "prima materia") - that is, man in his ordinary state. Man as he is is unwise and uninitiated; selfish and base; corruptible, passible, and perishable.

From here, the alchemist grows in wisdom (self-knowledge) and comes to know himself fully. As he comes to know himself,  he sees the parts of himself that horrify him or that contradict his self-assured opinions. There is a great unmaking of all his earlier beliefs and ideations. This is the state of "putrefaction" or blackening, the creation of a chaotic black stew of unorganized ideas. If you notice, this state correlates with one we examined earlier - the state of purgation in mysticism.

(For those interested more in this state, I would recommend Carl Jung's writings on the "shadow self," or the work The Dark Night of the Soul by John of the Cross.)

The chief tool the alchemist works with here is the "fire" or furnace. The stone goes through many chemical transformations and is also put into a crucible which cleanses it of its imperfections. This I think may reflect the feeling of contradiction when one grows in self-knowledge; of suffering; or of personal adversity that helps to elevate or ennoble one.

The second state is that of whitening. In time the chaotic mess of blackness is purified; perhaps the negative elements are expurged or evaporate. The confused notions form into a coherent vision of oneself and the world. Man comes to a new understanding of his place in the cosmos. This is the state of "whitening" and we find the equivalent here with illumination in mysticism.

In the final stages the stone is portrayed as turning yellow, and then reaching a final state in which it becomes either red or multicolored. At this point it is now the "lapis philosophorum" or philosopher's stone; the "great work" is completed and man reaches a state of personal perfection, enlightenment, and immortality. Here we find the equivalent with divinization in mysticism.

The Three Elements
The other model of the alchemical path often involves working with the following elements.

1. Mercury
2. Sulphur
3. Salt

The precise meaning of these elements depends on the context; but in most cases they represent on some level the "three parts" of the psyche.

If we use the division of the psyche described by Plato, we would correlate these elements with reason, anger, and passion. In the same scheme as The Republic, the alchemist's goal would be to bring these elements into a proper alignment; mercury should be the chief element, followed by sulphur and salt.

Another model would label these elements spirit, mind, and body. The goal with this approach would be to use the combination of the latter two (sulphur and salt) to produce the dynamic element mercury, which represents the imperishable spirit.

Other Allegories
Alchemy is a vast discipline, and there are other models beyond these two. Alchemy also likes to use many symbols, sometimes involving astronomy (sol = gold or divinization; luna = silver or illumination) or zoology (lions - the most famous being the "green lion," the bold but fledgling seeker of the transcendent - or ravens, usually a symbol of the stage of putrefaction).