Monday, February 3, 2020

Conducive or Not Conducive to the Spiritual Life

Archived post from Jeff's forum. Always very interesting stuff on there from time to time.

~

Intuition wrote:

Hello everyone! It's been a while since I've posted. I've started a new job recently, so it's taken alot of my attention.

There have been 2 recurring topics that I'd like to get others' thoughts on.

-Pursuing mundane knowledge such as knowledge of mathematics, history, one's profession, etc: How is the pursual of mundane knowledge such as knowledge of one's profession, mathematics, etc related to the spiritual path? Is it a distraction that takes attention and energy away from the spiritual path? Or is it helpful? Or is it neither?

-lifestyle (stressful or not in the relative world): Should one strive to make one's life as stress-free as possible to devote more attention to the Spiritual path? (choosing not to have kids, choosing to have a job where you have to work less, living off the grid, etc). Or does it not matter?

I'm currently someone who works alot, and studies alot (mathematics and computing). I've got options, though. In the future, I could even work remotely and live in a much cheaper country, and only need to work about 1 out of every 4 years.

I see a couple roads before me.

1- I devote alot of time to my career and my field. I spend tons of time studying maths and AI (which I enjoy), and I perhaps even take time from work to get my PHD. Bright future in the field (I have the work ethic and discipline for it), very comfortable amount of money, living in the US.

2-I still stay in my current field, but I don't go deep into it, into AI and all the mathematics required, doing something that is perhaps less intellectually satisfying, yet provides comfortable wages and requires about 1000 hours less time from me to break into, and I work remotely, living in a cheaper country, and probably need to work about 1/4 as much due to this fact.

Years ago, I experienced the results of mystical praxes (and I still do), which I've found to be of innate good and value. since then, gnosis and spirituality have been my ultimate endeavors in life, and so I always want these to be my ultimate guiding light and compass.

~

Alexander wrote:

One of the intuitions I had at an early age, Intuition, echoed what Solomon said in Ecclesiastes, "vanity of vanities, all is vanity." Human life is short, it will be over before we know it, and the real work is the preparation for death. This realization informed a lot of the decisions I made for learning, career, and so on. Though things have worked out OK, at the same time I've pondered off and on if I followed the right course. For example, I could have pursued engineering, or a different field, instead.

Lately I've been teaching, which gives a good amount of free time, which is very compatible with the spiritual life. If I were in Europe this would not be as big a deal, as working class jobs there provide more time off. But, here in the States it was a good course for work/life balance. However, it is also a path that brings its own stresses and insecurities, does not pay very well, and does not provide a lot of status in society.

At one point I considered becoming a monk, but I also have very little patience for institutional religion and would likely rankle under all the unnecessary rules. I also felt that as a modern person, in many ways it was not appropriate to follow a monastic path. Certainly I may have done so in a previous era; but for a life in the 2000s no. I ended up studying philosophy (again something I could have done without the university degree :p), exploring many different intellectual and religious traditions in the process, without the baggage of dogma.

One thing I have internalized, is that my long term goal is to maximize my freedom, so I can dedicate more to spiritual pursuits. This resulted in my changing my view of personal finance in my mid-20s. I did not put any thought into money before 25 ("do not worry about what you wear, or what you will eat..."), but I started to become a lot more practical about it. I worked for a short time at a bank and that got me more interested in investing. I was always very frugal ("what is the need for physical comforts?" - very ascetical type of attitude) and incidentally from this was saving a lot. At the bank I got to thinking "why not find a way to make these savings grow?" which got me interested in buy-and-hold investing, using savings to buy stocks with dividends, and letting them compound.

On the web there is the idea of "FIRE," financial independence and retire early, which despite my modest income I have been building towards as a long term goal. So, save as large a percentage of the income as possible, invest it in large cap dividend or growth stocks, and let the portfolio compound over time. Then, the dream is to be able to retire early and be able to live off those savings. The idea here would be (if successful) retire or start working part time by 40, then be free to dedicate whatever time was desired to spiritual pursuits.

This has been an interesting development, because it is actually a contradictory view of money. In other words, I have both a disparaging ascetical view of it, and also a practical embrace of it. There is a famous sociologist Max Weber who said this is called the "Protestant work ethic," as a lot of the people who founded the New England colonies here in the States had this similar idea, and Weber said that incidentally it led those settlers (the Pilgrims) to prosper. So, make of that what you will.

Here I have to confess a few things about my own experience of the contemplative life. As a teenager I read the great mystics of history, the accounts of the ecstasies, samadhi, and so on, and I always imagined my practice of meditation would bring great fruits. However, for myself this has not been the case. Though I experience energy and vibrations, they have never turned into some spectacular state. I have never experienced a "nondual" state in which I lose a sense of "I." And I have never had an experience in which I have consciously left the body. While this is irregular for someone on this forum, I have been reading more on OOB forums, and it seems like this is typical there. Many people meditate or attempt OOBEs for years, and experience no spectacular phenomena, and unfortunately this has been the case for me. This was very distressing to me for some time, as I have always felt my "main focus" has been spiritual matters, but I have gradually accepted it with idea of "amor fati" (love your fate) and that it is "God's will" and one should "submit."

So in my own case the contemplative life has not been particularly impressive. And even when I dedicate many hours in the evening to the practice, I am underwhelmed by what results. So in this regard I am starting to become a lot more skeptical of my young idealism about what the contemplative life is, that for the most part it is very mundane and unfantastic, that it is more a hard life of simplicity and sacrifice. While I am filled now with esoteric wisdom that the layperson does not ever encounter, have certain knowledge of phenomena the average person cannot understand, and have conquered sorrow, loneliness, anger, and so forth, I cannot say it has reformed me into some type of spectacular "superhuman." It also provokes the question of, "is more free time than I have now really required?" Or, if I should lead a balanced life and pursue a family, finance, pleasure, and other ends (in Hinduism, they call this the four Purusarthas).

Recently I was watching an interview with William Buhlman (the successor to Bob Monroe, the coiner of the term "OOBE"), who has certainly impressed me with his experience and wisdom. And, he offered a very interesting point. That we are here in the human realm because living out this existence is precisely the point of it. That by living out your life you are fulfilling your purpose - learning and growing, and developing wisdom. So, I would not be averse to the experience of the here and now, but just like you embrace the spiritual life, you embrace the human experience as well. :)

~

Jeff wrote:

Thank-you friends for posting here some very interesting ideas.  I guess I will just tell you my story, and possibly it will at least fill out this inquiry, and it might help some of you decide what to do with your life.

I started meditating in the midle of 1973.  By my birthday in 1974 I had learned to still my mind, become lucid in the dream state, and had mastered the OOBE, as well as having negotiated 7 of the 8 stages of samadhi.  On that birthday I dedicated my whole life to the spiritual endeavor, and taken up a celibit life.  I wandered about as a mendicant ariving in Santa Barbara, CA, and spending the remainder of the summer there.  There I camped on the beach, practiced meditation and Tai Chi on the beach, and met some people.  By the end of the summer, I had no place to go, and there did not seem to be any movement forward, so I decided to head back to Tucson.

The problem that faces the dedicated contemplative becomes a livelihood.  At that time I decided that an ethical livelihood, which would increase my meditation time was doing healing work.  Doing that work, plus being a dedicated contemplative I developed a small reputation, which gave me a modest income.

One of the criticisms that I received from people was I was too young and inexperienced to become a spiritual teacher.  I should marry and have children.  So, I met a woman in 1976. We got married.  Marriage meant I had to bring in more money, so I got a job, and developed a career.  Along the way we had a couple of kids, then we ended up divorced, so I had 2 children to support, so I had to work harder.  All along I kept up my meditation practice of 3 sessions per day.

Looking back now after 45 years, while I love my children, and I am very proud of them; nonetheless, marrige and children and a career has been a massive distraction.  For me I would have been better off staying celibate and living as a mendicant, wandering, and possibly never developing a spiritual leadership role.  or, I could have kept the healing work going, which would have produced a modest income. Either way, my spiritual life would have been more fulfilling.

There is a downside to being a dedicated mendicant, which leads to poverty.  Spiritual  groups need to be funded.  Who is going to fund that group?  Well, in 67 years on this planet most of the funding has come from me.  Yes, people do fund the GWV (thank-you very much); however, I am clearly not long for this world, and when I go, so is likely the GWV. 

What happens when I die?  I expect that the GWV will crumble due to lack of funding, and all of the work done here, and elsewhere, will be forgotten.  Many of us have studied the mystics, and what I see in the history of mystics and mysticism is most of the mystics are never recorded.  Of those who leave behind a legacy will either be demonized, or find their legacy corrupted by a pretnetious and hypocritical preisthood, who will mislead people, as all mainstream religions are an example.

I see that being a mystic requires a great deal of youthful effort, which does not come to the person who had a career and a family, then retired and took up a contemplative life.  However, that person in retirement might have acquired a savings that he, or she, could use to fund a religious movement.

In hindsight, the path that I led as a dedicated contemplative doing healing work, or just being a mendicant foraging seems like either would have been the best choice.

So, in conclusion what we do is up to each and everyone of us/  I can only recommend meditating skillfully 3 to 6 times a day.  And, chances are the world will ignore you, or quickly forget you.  So, develope no attachments, and lead a lifelong spiritual life.